I want to understand the practical difference between Best Speed and Smallest Area in FPGA . - I want to understand the practical difference between Best Speed and Smallest Area in FPGA .
Hello, I currently have an SCFIFO application requirement. The FPGA device I am using is the 10M02SCM153C8G , and I am implementing the FIFO function through an IP core. My application seemed quite simple at first, so when generating the FIFO, I selected the Best Speed option. However, after actual testing, I found that the FIFO generated by the FPGA IP was unstable . The symptom was that the image would occasionally and intermittently split. After that, I changed the FIFO setting to Smallest Area , and the problem became much more stable. I am still testing it. Why is there such a difference? What is the reason? My current goal is to use the FPGA’s internal FIFO to replace the external 72V251 FIFO , because this device has been discontinued, so I am looking for a feasible replacement solution. Thank you for your reply.
Replies:
Re: I want to understand the practical difference between Best Speed and Smallest Area in FPGA .
Hi My goal is to design an SCFIFO using an FPGA to replace an obsolete component. I looked into the issue and consulted AI, which aligned with your point: adopting the "best speed" optimization would insert an additional register and introduce an extra cycle of latency. However, since the firmware is completely fixed and cannot be modified on my end, managing this extra latency solely within the FPGA logic is quite challenging for me. Given our application—where the FPGA receives image data from a sensor and forwards it to a PC via a USB interface—I believe the "small area" configuration might be a better fit for our requirements. My operating frequency is 48 MHz.
Replies:
Re: I want to understand the practical difference between Best Speed and Smallest Area in FPGA .
Hi, Richard Thank you. I have already solved the problem.
Replies:
Re: I want to understand the practical difference between Best Speed and Smallest Area in FPGA .
Does sstrell’s suggestion address your inquiry? Do you need any further assistance? Regards, Richard Tna
Replies:
Re: I want to understand the practical difference between Best Speed and Smallest Area in FPGA .
I'm not sure what "the image would occasionally and intermittently split" means as the issue, but is your design meeting timing? How fast are you running it? Like it says there, best speed is inserting an additional register. Are you taking into account this extra cycle of latency elsewhere in your design? - 2026-06-22
external_document
- Resource Type
- Support Resources > Forums
- Source Name
- khoros